The Confession

Chapter 17 — Laura

The drive took forty minutes. Michael rode in the back of Laura Kim’s unmarked car, hands cuffed loosely in his lap — she had insisted on procedure, and he had not argued. There was a strange comfort in it, in being handled the way any man would be handled. No collar. No deference. Just the law, doing what the law does.

Through the window, the desert slid past in its late-morning glare: creosote and sand, the far blue ridge of the Sangre de Cristos, a red-tailed hawk circling something dead or dying in a thermal. He had made this drive a hundred times as a priest — to visit the sick, to bury the dead, to bring communion to the ranch families at the end of the dirt roads. He had never made it like this. He kept waiting for the landscape to look different, charged with meaning, but it looked exactly the same, which was somehow worse. The desert didn’t care. It had never cared.

“You don’t have to be here for the excavation,” Laura said from the front seat, watching him in the rearview mirror. Her voice was professional, but there was something underneath it he couldn’t place. “Your statement is enough to authorize it. Nobody would think less of you for waiting at the station.”

“I want to be here,” Michael said. “I put him there. I should be there when he comes out.”

She studied him a moment longer in the mirror, then nodded and turned her eyes back to the road.

They parked where the cliff road ended, in the same turnout where Michael had left his truck that July night twenty years ago, and walked the last stretch on foot. The crime scene team was already there — white tents, equipment cases, a forensic anthropologist from Albuquerque kneeling by the rock hollow with a brush and a sifter. The hollow was exactly as Michael remembered it: a cleft in the stone at the cliff’s foot, half-shaded by the overhang, filled with twenty years of windblown sand. He had dreamed of it for two decades without knowing what he was dreaming. Now he stood at its mouth in the daylight, a cuffed man in a black shirt with the collar removed, and the wind moved through the rocks with a low, hollow sound, and he pointed.

“There,” he said. “Under the overhang. I put him as far back as I could. I covered him with sand — I used my hands. It took a long time.”

Laura walked with him to the edge of the tape and stood beside him. The wind was up; dust moved in low ribbons across the sand, and the crime scene techs worked in the patient, silent rhythm of people who do this for a living. Michael found himself praying — not for escape, not for mercy, but that it would be quick, that David would not have to wait any longer, that the earth would give him up gently.

It was nearly two hours before the anthropologist sat back on her heels and looked up at Laura. The look was enough. Laura’s shoulders dropped a fraction, and she turned away for a moment, one hand pressed to her mouth, and Michael understood that she had hoped — against her own evidence, against everything — that he had been wrong. That the hollow would be empty. That this part, at least, would turn out to be another one of his mind’s inventions.

“Positive ID will take time,” the anthropologist said quietly, coming over to them, pulling off her gloves. “Dental records, DNA against the family reference sample. But the position, the trauma pattern — a fall from that height, consistent with the ledge above.” She glanced up at the cliff, a sheer drop of pale rock. “And the fabric fragment Detective Kim recovered earlier matches material found with the remains. Same shirt. Same weave.”

Michael closed his eyes. He heard Laura give orders — photographs, grid mapping, chain of custody — her voice crisp and professional, the voice of a woman who had done this before and would do it again. Then he felt her hand on his elbow, light, and he opened his eyes, and she was looking at him with an expression he had not expected. Not triumph. Not the satisfaction of a case closed. Something softer, and harder to bear.

“You told the truth,” she said.

“I told part of it,” Michael said. “There’s more. There’s something I haven’t told anyone — something I didn’t understand until —” He stopped. The hollow behind them, the tents, the wind. “Can we go back to the station? There’s something I need to see. Something you have.”

On the drive back she uncuffed him — a small mercy, procedure bent at the edges — and he rubbed his wrists and watched the desert go by, and neither of them spoke until the town came into view. Then Laura said, without taking her eyes off the road, “The second and third visits. You’ve been turning something over.”

Michael looked at her. “How did you know?”

“Because I would be.” She glanced at him. “Whatever it is, we’ll face it at the station. Together, if you want.”

They drove back in silence. The hawk was gone from the sky. The desert slid past, indifferent, and Michael watched it and thought about the stranger’s voice through the confessional screen, and about the second and third visits, and about a detail that had been scratching at the back of his mind since the excavation began — a wrongness he couldn’t name yet.

In the interview room — the same room where he had sat three weeks ago as a cooperating witness, a priest helping the police, a man with nothing to hide — Laura set a laptop on the table between them and turned the screen toward him. Her face was unreadable now, all detective again.

“There’s something you need to see,” she said.

—